Key Points
- Biffa is appealing the dismissal of its £51.4 million damages claim against the Scottish Government.
- The company says a 2022 letter from former minister Lorna Slater created a misleading impression about the deposit return scheme.
- Biffa’s lawyers argue that Lord Sandison made errors in law when rejecting the original claim.
- The Scottish Government says the appeal raises irrelevant new legal arguments and should be dismissed.
- The Inner House of the Court of Session is expected to issue a written judgment later.
Edinburgh (Cardiff Daily) November 18, 2026 – Waste management company Biffa has returned to court seeking compensation from the Scottish Government after the failure of Scotland’s planned deposit return scheme for bottles and cans. Biffa is appealing against the dismissal of its £51.4 million claim for losses linked to investments made for the scheme. The company says former minister Lorna Slater’s 2022 letter gave an inaccurate impression that the scheme would proceed on schedule. The Scottish Government disputes the appeal and says Biffa’s new legal arguments are irrelevant.
- Key Points
- Why is Biffa appealing the £51.4 million claim ruling?
- What does the Scottish Government say?
- How did the deposit return scheme fail?
- What did the original judgment decide?
- What happens next for Biffa and the recycling scheme?
- What is the background to the dispute?
- How could the appeal affect businesses involved in recycling schemes?
Why is Biffa appealing the £51.4 million claim ruling?
As reported by the BBC in “Waste firm appeals over £51m recycling scheme damages claim”, Biffa argues that Ms Slater’s letter was a negligent misrepresentation because it did not disclose difficulties involving UK internal market rules. The company says the letter was a “half truth” and that ministers should have warned it that the scheme could be blocked.
The Northern Echo reported that Biffa’s lawyers told a three-judge panel that Lord Sandison had erred in law while analysing the evidence. Andrew McWhirter said the judge was wrong to conclude that the letter of May 17, 2022, was not a negligent misrepresentation. Roddy Dunlop KC argued that the letter could be accurate while still misleading because it omitted information that ministers knew could undermine the scheme.
Biffa’s lawyers also referred to a 2002 case involving the Spice Girls, arguing that failing to disclose material information can create legal responsibility in some circumstances. Mr Dunlop asked the court to uphold the appeal.
What does the Scottish Government say?
The Scottish Government has urged the court to reject the appeal. Its lawyers argue that the points raised by Biffa do not justify overturning Lord Sandison’s ruling.
According to the BBC report, King’s Counsel Gerry Moynihan said evidence from the original proceedings showed that Biffa did not treat Ms Slater’s letter as a guarantee that the scheme would be delivered. He said the company had recognised risks outside the government’s control and had introduced measures including insurance against delay or cancellation.
Lord Sandison previously concluded that there was no duty of care owed to Biffa. He also found that the company could have sought further information about legal obstacles before signing its contract but did not do so.
How did the deposit return scheme fail?
The proposed Scottish scheme would have required consumers to pay an additional 20 pence on single-use bottles and cans, with the charge refunded when containers were returned for recycling. Biffa had been appointed as the scheme’s main logistics partner.
The plan was suspended in 2023 after a dispute between the Scottish and United Kingdom governments over internal market rules. Former Scottish Secretary Alister Jack declined to grant an exemption, preventing the Scottish Government from proceeding with plans that included glass bottles.
Former minister Lorna Slater told an earlier hearing that Mr Jack had undermined the scheme for political reasons. Mr Jack said the Scottish Government had acted incompetently and irresponsibly by failing to warn Biffa about the risks. The head of Circularity Scotland, the organisation established to manage the scheme, said he felt betrayed because material facts had not been disclosed.
What did the original judgment decide?
In January 2026, Lord Sandison dismissed Biffa’s £51.4 million claim, finding that it failed in fact and law. He described Biffa’s interpretation of Ms Slater’s letter as “wishful thinking” and said a reasonable person would not have understood it as assuring the scheme’s legislative sufficiency.
The judge also concluded that Ms Slater and Mr Jack had given evidence truthfully and in good faith. Biffa says the factual findings can support its case if the appeal court corrects the alleged errors of law.
What happens next for Biffa and the recycling scheme?
The appeal was heard by Lady Wick, Lord Pentland and Lord Ericht in the Inner House of the Court of Session. A written judgment will be issued at a later date.
The outcome will determine whether Biffa can revive its claim for compensation or whether the original dismissal stands. For waste companies, logistics contractors and investors considering government-backed recycling infrastructure, the ruling could clarify how far official statements and undisclosed regulatory risks may affect commercial contracts.
A United Kingdom-wide deposit return scheme is due to begin in October 2027, meaning the appeal may also draw attention to the legal and commercial risks surrounding future recycling schemes.
What is the background to the dispute?
Biffa agreed to work as the principal logistics partner for Scotland’s deposit return scheme and made investments in preparation for its launch. The company later claimed that the scheme’s collapse caused £51.4 million in losses. The initiative was delayed and ultimately suspended after disagreements between the Scottish and United Kingdom governments over internal market rules. Lord Sandison rejected Biffa’s claim in January 2026, prompting the current appeal.
How could the appeal affect businesses involved in recycling schemes?
A decision in Biffa’s favour could encourage contractors and investors to seek stronger assurances before committing funds to government-backed recycling programmes. It could also increase scrutiny of ministerial correspondence, risk disclosures and contractual safeguards. If the Scottish Government prevails, companies may face greater pressure to conduct independent legal and regulatory checks rather than rely on political assurances. The ruling could therefore influence negotiations for the planned United Kingdom-wide deposit return scheme due in 2027.
