Key Points
- Unchanged Devolution Policy: Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates confirmed that the party remains committed to calling for Westminster to devolve control of policing and the Crown Estate to the Senedd.
- Shift in Political Focus: While policy has not changed, Skates stated that Welsh Labour had previously spent too much time debating powers from Westminster rather than discussing devolving powers onward to local communities across Wales.
- Election Post-Mortem Findings: An independent report by Professor Anand Menon’s PF First into Welsh Labour’s May Senedd election defeat criticised former First Minister Eluned Morgan’s “Red Welsh Way” strategy, noting that calls for more powers had failed to resonate with voters.
- Defence of Former Leadership: Skates defended Morgan’s tenure, stating she inherited an “unwinnable situation” in 2025, “steadied the ship”, and “cleaned up the boy’s mess” left by a divided Senedd group following Vaughan Gething’s resignation.
- Party Unity and Future Direction: Despite dropping from holding half of the Senedd’s seats to just nine Members of the Senedd (MSs) in the 96-member parliament, Skates insisted the party is now completely united and focused on improving “health and wealth for all”.
Llandudno (Cardiff Daily) November 16, 2026 – Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates has insisted that his party has not abandoned its demand for the devolution of policing and the Crown Estate from Westminster, despite telling the party conference that Labour had previously focused too heavily on acquiring new powers. Speaking to BBC Wales programmes following the conclusion of the party’s conference in Llandudno, Skates defended former First Minister Eluned Morgan against critical findings in a post-election review and declined to say whether Prime Minister Andy Burnham would be wrong to refuse further devolution.
- Key Points
- Has Welsh Labour Dropped Its Demand for Policing and Crown Estate Powers?
- Why Did the Election Report Criticise the “Red Welsh Way” Strategy?
- Is Welsh Labour Abandoning “Clear Red Water” to Unite the Party?
- Background
- Prediction: How Could This Development Affect Welsh Voters and Devolution Policy?
Has Welsh Labour Dropped Its Demand for Policing and Crown Estate Powers?
As reported by BBC News, Ken Skates confirmed that Welsh Labour’s official policy regarding the transfer of powers over policing and the Crown Estate remains entirely intact. During an appearance on the BBC Politics Wales programme, Skates sought to clarify remarks he made during his conference speech on Saturday, in which he argued that Welsh Labour had previously treated standing up for Wales solely as a quest for additional powers for the Welsh Parliament.
When pressed by BBC Politics Wales on whether the party was still actively calling for powers over the Crown Estate and policing, Skates stated:
“I’ve been really clear, you know, we need transfers of powers on the basis of what’s best for Wales from Westminster to Cardiff Bay, but that’s been the focus of all debate for far too long. We haven’t had a good debate, deep debate, about what powers need to be transferred onward from Cardiff Bay to places like Aberystwyth, Wrexham, and Merthyr, to communities right across Wales.”
When the BBC Politics Wales programme pressed him on the exact same question for a second time, Skates replied:
“Yes, yes, and there’s been no change in policy on that.”
What Is Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s Stance on Devolution?
As reported by BBC News, Skates would not be drawn on whether it would be wrong for Prime Minister Andy Burnham to refuse the devolution of policing and the Crown Estate. Asked directly on the programme if Burnham would be wrong to block those transfers, Skates stated:
“This is a live debate that’s taking place at the moment, and our party policy in Wales has not changed.”
According to BBC News, Prime Minister Andy Burnham has previously signalled that he was open to the devolution of policing, although no firm proposals have yet been put forward by the UK government. Conversely, the UK government has previously argued that devolving the Crown Estate would make no commercial sense.
Owned by the monarch, the Crown Estate holds more than £603m worth of land in Wales, including 65% of the seabed surrounding the Welsh coastline. Both Welsh Labour and Plaid Cymru maintain that the estate should be devolved so that revenues generated from offshore wind farms and other marine projects can be spent exclusively in Wales.
Why Did the Election Report Criticise the “Red Welsh Way” Strategy?
As reported by BBC News, Skates’s comments followed the presentation of an internal review at the Llandudno conference—which concluded on Sunday—examining the causes of Welsh Labour’s heavy defeat in the Senedd elections in May. The report, compiled by Professor Anand Menon’s organisation PF First, criticised the “Red Welsh Way” political strategy championed by former First Minister Eluned Morgan, concluding that demands for additional constitutional powers had fallen flat with the electorate.
Speaking earlier on BBC Radio Wales’ Sunday Supplement programme, Skates rejected the characterisation of Professor Menon’s review as a punitive document. As reported by BBC News, Skates stated that the report was not a “charge sheet” but rather outlined “what went wrong over many, many years”, while pointing toward a roadmap for how Welsh Labour can recover.
How Did Ken Skates Defend Former First Minister Eluned Morgan?
As reported by BBC News, Skates strongly defended Eluned Morgan’s leadership during both his Saturday conference address and his Sunday broadcast interviews. During his conference speech on Saturday, Skates said Morgan had “steadied the ship” when she became Welsh Labour leader “in the most difficult of times and the worst set of conditions”, adding that she had “cleaned up the boy’s mess”.
When asked by BBC News whether he took personal responsibility for contributing to that “boy’s mess”—given that he had served as co-chair of the leadership campaign to elect Vaughan Gething, who subsequently had to resign—Skates replied:
“Oh no, it wasn’t just that. This was about the dysfunctional nature of the Senedd group. It was divided, and it was largely divided because of the boys. She came in the most difficult of times, and she led with incredible passion.”
On BBC Radio Wales’ Sunday Supplement, Skates reinforced his defence of his predecessor, stating:
“What’s clear from the report is that Eluned was in an unwinnable situation when she took over leadership. We didn’t lose because of Eluned; we lost in spite of Eluned’s fierce, courageous leadership.”
Is Welsh Labour Abandoning “Clear Red Water” to Unite the Party?
As reported by BBC News, Skates denied that Welsh Labour had dropped either the “Red Welsh Way” or the long-standing “clear red water” doctrine—both of which have historically been used to establish distinct policy positions separating Welsh Labour from the UK Labour leadership in Westminster. Explaining the origin of Morgan’s approach, Skates said the Red Welsh Way was
“in response to divided opinion in the party at the time”.
Outlining the party’s current posture, Skates stated that Welsh Labour would move forward
“fighting as one team with a distinct offer to people and that is that we are going to seek health and wealth for all. Other parties have their own priorities.”
He added:
“Our purpose is to make sure that people’s lives improve and we’ll be asking right across the parliamentary Labour Party and councils in the trade union movement and of course in the Senedd, [is] what we’re doing making people better off?”
Despite the scale of the party’s electoral losses, Skates maintained that internal divisions had been resolved.
“We’re a different party now. OK, we’re smaller in number, but we are completely united in the Senedd. That helps in terms of ensuring that everybody is fighting for the same purpose,”
he told the BBC.
Background
Prior to the Senedd election in May, Welsh Labour held half of the available seats in the Welsh Parliament, continuing a long period of dominance in devolved Welsh politics. However, the party experienced severe internal turbulence leading up to the poll. Vaughan Gething’s brief tenure as First Minister ended in resignation following political controversies, leaving a fractured Senedd group.
Eluned Morgan assumed the leadership and office of First Minister in 2025, attempting to reassert a distinct Welsh identity for the party through the “Red Welsh Way” platform. In the May election, Welsh Labour suffered a historic collapse, emerging with just nine Members of the Senedd in the newly expanded 96-member parliament.
Prediction: How Could This Development Affect Welsh Voters and Devolution Policy?
For voters across Wales, Welsh Labour’s recalibration indicates a shift in political messaging away from constitutional debates between Cardiff Bay and Westminster toward tangible, everyday concerns such as healthcare, living standards, and local council empowerment. For local communities in areas such as Aberystwyth, Wrexham, and Merthyr, Skates’s emphasis on transferring powers onward from Cardiff Bay could lead to renewed proposals for municipal or regional devolution within Wales.
Meanwhile, for stakeholders in the renewable energy sector and advocates of Welsh fiscal autonomy, the unchanged commitment to devolving the £603m Crown Estate keeps offshore wind revenue sharing on the political agenda, though its practical realisation remains contingent on negotiations with Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s UK government, which has previously resisted transferring the asset on commercial grounds.
