Key Points
- Professor Peter Hindmarsh was barred from treating patients by University College London Hospitals in March 2023, during Lucy Letby’s trial.
- The hospital told the General Medical Council that it considered his clinical advice unsafe for children and young people.
- A medical tribunal declined to suspend his registration but required direct supervision of his clinical work.
- Letby’s defence was aware of a General Medical Council investigation but was reportedly not told about the clinical ban or tribunal decision.
- The development could support arguments in Letby’s application to the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
Inverted pyramid: the most significant development is that a prosecution expert whose evidence was central to Lucy Letby’s convictions had been excluded from clinical practice over patient-safety concerns while her trial was still under way.
- Key Points
- What did University College London Hospitals report about Peter Hindmarsh?
- What did the medical tribunal decide?
- Why could the information matter to Lucy Letby’s conviction?
- What is the wider dispute over the evidence?
- What could happen next for the Letby case?
- Background to Professor Peter Hindmarsh’s involvement
- How might this affect the case before its particular audience?
Manchester (Cardiff Daily) November 18, 2026 – Professor Peter Hindmarsh, the paediatric endocrinologist whose evidence helped prosecutors argue that Lucy Letby poisoned two babies with insulin, was barred from treating patients by University College London Hospitals in March 2023 during her trial. The hospital told the General Medical Council that it could not accept the level of risk he appeared to pose to children and young people, including concerns about advice relating to insulin. Letby’s defence team was not informed of the ban or a subsequent tribunal ruling before the trial concluded.
What did University College London Hospitals report about Peter Hindmarsh?
As reported by The Guardian, UCLH medical director Dr Tim Hodgson told the General Medical Council that Professor Hindmarsh had given independent advice involving three children despite restrictions on his clinical work. Two cases concerned insulin and diabetes. In two cases, he allegedly advised families to stop giving insulin at home; one child later experienced diabetic ketoacidosis, a potentially fatal complication caused by severe insulin deficiency. Dr Hodgson said it was unclear whether the episode coincided with the alleged advice.
The hospital also raised concerns that Professor Hindmarsh focused excessively on rare explanations for low blood sugar and diabetes, did not address more common causes and did not treat high glucose levels appropriately. UCLH said written concerns had been submitted by medical colleagues.
What did the medical tribunal decide?
The General Medical Council applied to suspend Professor Hindmarsh’s registration. In April 2023, a three-person medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend him, saying suspension would be disproportionate. It found that the cases identified by UCLH raised patient-safety concerns and tightened the supervision requirement so that he would need direct supervision when treating patients.
The tribunal also allowed Professor Hindmarsh to continue non-clinical work, including acting as an expert witness. In practice, the order had limited effect on patient treatment because UCLH had already excluded him from clinical practice.
Why could the information matter to Lucy Letby’s conviction?
Professor Hindmarsh was presented to jurors as a leading authority on insulin. His evidence stated that medical results involving two babies were consistent with insulin poisoning, probably through intravenous fluid bags. Prosecutors described the alleged poisoning as decisive evidence, and the jury returned guilty verdicts on those charges.
The Guardian reported that Letby’s defence knew Professor Hindmarsh was subject to a General Medical Council investigation but was not told that UCLH had barred him from treating patients or that the tribunal had imposed further restrictions. The defence could have used the information to challenge his credibility, seek disclosure to the jury or apply to exclude his evidence.
Expert witnesses in criminal proceedings must disclose disciplinary proceedings and other information that might undermine their opinions or credibility. Letby’s lawyer Mark McDonald has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which can refer cases back to the Court of Appeal.
What is the wider dispute over the evidence?
Lucy Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others and received 15 whole-life terms. She has maintained her innocence, while the Court of Appeal has rejected her applications to appeal.
Several medical experts have challenged the prosecution’s interpretation of the cases. Dr Shoo Lee, a Canadian neonatologist, has said a panel of 14 experts found natural causes and poor medical care could explain the collapses and deaths and found no evidence of deliberate harm. Experts supporting Letby’s Criminal Cases Review Commission application have also questioned Professor Hindmarsh’s calculations, the alleged fluid-bag insulin route and the reliability of immunoassay blood tests.
Lady Justice Thirlwall’s public inquiry, which reported in September, examined failures in NHS management after the convictions and did not consider arguments that Letby may have suffered a miscarriage of justice while the Criminal Cases Review Commission application was pending.
What could happen next for the Letby case?
The disclosure could give Letby’s lawyers additional grounds to argue that the prosecution did not provide information capable of undermining an important expert witness. It does not itself overturn the convictions, and the Criminal Cases Review Commission would need to assess whether the information could have affected the verdicts or created a real possibility that the Court of Appeal would quash them.
If the commission refers the case, the Court of Appeal would decide whether the convictions remain safe. If no referral is made, the convictions and sentences will remain in force unless another legal route succeeds.
Background to Professor Peter Hindmarsh’s involvement
Professor Hindmarsh was a consultant paediatric endocrinologist at University College London Hospitals and a professor at University College London. The General Medical Council opened an investigation into his fitness to practise in November 2022, the same day he first gave evidence for the prosecution. Great Ormond Street Hospital and UCLH had reported concerns involving his diagnosis and treatment of patients. The prosecution relied on his interpretation of insulin-related evidence in the Letby trial, while Letby’s defence was not told about his later clinical exclusion.
How might this affect the case before its particular audience?
For Letby’s legal team and supporters seeking a Criminal Cases Review Commission referral, the development may strengthen claims that the jury should have known about restrictions placed on a central prosecution expert. For prosecutors, the issue is whether the undisclosed information materially affected Professor Hindmarsh’s credibility or the reliability of his opinions used at trial. For the General Medical Council and NHS trusts, the case highlights the need to manage expert witnesses transparently when clinical safety investigations overlap with criminal proceedings. The convictions remain legally valid unless a court changes them.
